Talkback? Have you read those before? What percent of those comments, by Israelis, Jews, Arabs, and other interested parties offer thoughtful responses? 1? 5? Certainly no higher than that.

That said, as an Israeli, I would like to point out that the cold peace between Israel and Egypt is disappointing. An agreement has been in place for decades and yet the relatively new accord with Jordan has led to vastly more cultural and economic relations between the former rivals. Perhaps it is wishful thinking to have hoped that warmer ties between Israel and Egypt could have developed.

And it is clear to many in Israel that Egypt has played a positive and important role in trying to curb instability in the Palestinian Authority. As I recall, one of its representatives was injured in an exchange of gunfire between Fatah and Hamas gunmen just the other day in the midst of a mediation attempt. And for that, Israelis need to be grateful.

Also, it is disconcerting that the Egyptian government-controlled media continues to rail invective against Israel. The mixture of anti-Jewish caricatures and exaggerated political accusations against Israel do not help encourage neighborly feelings.

Patrick, you wrote above that Israel has “clear and utter contempt for Egypt’s basic existence.” That is not the case – at all. Israelis actually have a great deal of respect for and interest in Egyptian culture and history. Israelis visit Egypt on a regular basis. Even the ongoing bombings in the Sinai that targetted tourist centers frequented by Israelis has not completely discouraged Israeli tourists.

So don’t place too much stock in Gilad Sharon’s article. Very few in Israel do.

On the stance of Egypt and Israel I agree with you, I just disagree with you kind of claiming as if Egypt truly cares about domestic stability or peace when it throws people in prison for criticisms and “defaming the reputation of Egypt.” Its harassments are disgusting and laughable.