Networking Arab Journalists around the world
Back in 1999, a group of Arab American journalists working in mainstream media jobs or in the Arab ethnic media, launched an organization called the National Arab American Journalists Association (NAAJA.) Our web page is www.NAAJA-US.com. We continue to try to bring Arab journalists together on a professional level. Networking is so important to success. By networking, we can help each other find jobs, protect ourselves to keep our jobs and fight discrimination; racism is a rampant disease in the United States and the main targets these days are Arabs and non-Arab Muslims. Most Americans can’t tell the difference between Arabs and non-Arabs and they often use the terms Muslim and Arab interchangeably. (Americans are the most educated people in the world but the least educated about the world. I love to use that in my comedy routine — by the way, there is a nice story in the Baltimore Sun on the comedy tour www.IPComedyTour.com.)
It hasn’t been easy, as you can imagine. We think of ourselves as “Arabs” but oftentimes Arabs tend to break down into small groups based on other considerations like nationality, ethnicity, of course politics and religion. But the word Arab reflects a cultural and national bond constantly tested by local national needs. The biggest challenge is the rise of Islamic political activism. Arabs do not distinguish themselves as being Christian or Muslim. There are also many Jewish Arabs that no one wants to talk much about, but they do exist. But many Muslim Arabs are being drawn into the growing power circle of Muslims, most of whom are not Arab at all.
This may not seem like an issue in the Middle East, where Islam defines the day-to-day lifestyle, but it is a growing issue in the United States where the majority of Arabs are Muslim. There are anout 7.5 million Muslims in the United States but only 22 percent are Arab. The largest group of “Black Muslims” or members of the Nation of Islam. There are about 4.5 million Arabs in the United States, and the majority are Christian (Catholic, Orthodox and Protestant).
We don’t have precise data because one way to oppress people is to not recognize them. The US Census does not include “Arabs” as a racial category. Only those Arabs who check “Other” and then write in “Arab” are actually counted as Arab, so the numbers are very low.
Not being recognized is how Americans tend to discriminate against people based on race and religion. It is a subtle form of discrimination but I think a more sinister form of discrimination. In the old days, people would tell you to your face that they hate you. Racism was obvious and open. But these days, Americans are more subtle in their racism. They say hi and smile, but deep down they hate you. That kind of disguised racism is more sisnister and destructive to a society. You can’t deal with it, especially when the society doesn’t deal with racism and diversity issues correctly.
In the American media, the big issue is “diversity.” But the racial minority groups that champion this call are also very discriminatory. African Americans and Hispanics have found themselves ina rivalry competing for jobs, power and influence in America. Now, Asians and Native Americans have come knocking at the door of diversity. As a result, mainstream Americans address “diversity” in a very narrow context, speaking only about Blacks, Hispanics, Asians and Native Americans.
Excluded are Arab Americans. We live in a limbo. We’re considered Caucasian (White), but we are treated worse than other minorities of color. It’s like an American purgatory, being hated and rejected or excluded by all sides. And then, of course, we have our own internal problems. Arabs hate each othe rmore than they are hated by others.
There’s an old saying I like to repeat about Arab culture: The Devil was giving a tour of Hell to an Arab, an American and a Jew. The Devil stopped at the first Cave and everyone looked in and they saw a big vat of boiling oil with “bad” Jews in it. The Devil’s disciples were standing on the edge of the Vat pushing the bad peopel back down with their pitchforks. They went to the next cave (it is very hot in Hell) and they saw the same situation with the Americans. When they got to the Arab Cave, there was a vat of boiling oil filled with “bad” Arabs but there were no disciples on the edge of the vat with pitchforks. The Arab turned to the Devil and said, “We must be special, right?” To which the Devil responded, “You sure are. I don’t need to waste my disciples on you. Whenever an Arab tries to lift himself up out of the vat of boiling oil, the other Arabs underneath grab him and pull him back down. You can always depend on an Arab to do that to his own kind.”
NAAJA has petitioned the “UNITY: Journalists of Color” to include Arab Americans in their member organizations (African Americans, Hispanics, Asians and Native Americans.) They have a big convention in Chicago next summer (2008). Either we will be apart of UNITY, or we will be outside. Hopefully, we won’t be pulling ourselves back down.
There are several Arab American journalism organizations. Why are we not surprised none of them will work together?
– Ray Hanania

Join the Conversation
Pingback: Global Voices Online » Mideast: Networking Arab Journalists
Hope you got sources to back that up.
On the first point, all you have to do is look at the Op-Ed pages of the major American newspapers and notice that they DON’T Include Arab columnists as often as they include non-Arabs on Arab and Muslim topics?
Does that count?
As for the bigotry, I think firsthand experience as the target of hatred in this country speaks for itself. Does that count?
Or, are you just upset because someone is in a position, finally, to raise the issue and expose the anti-Arab and anti-Muslim bigots in America?
thanks for writing
Ray Hanania
http://www.hanania.com
Ok Ray, I believe you. Arabs suffer from more bigotry than blacks and Latinos which is why they statistically graduate from college in higher percentages and and earn more money per household than even whites do!
In addition, hate crimes against Jews is nearly seven times higher than against Muslims (couldn’t find any statistics on Arabs). Even adjusting for population discrepancy, anti black hate crimes (you know the minorities that you assert suffer from less bigotry than Arabs and Muslims) is disproportionately higher than against Muslims…
http://www.fbi.gov/ucr/hc2005/victims.htm
Actually, Ray, ancedotal evidence doesn’t count for much.
That being said, you’re correct (IMO) that suspicion and distrust (even fear) of Muslims of any race and Arabs of any religion has been rising in America for some tme: does that surprise anyone? Does anyone think it’s unfounded paranoia? It does result in discrimination, but is not racism. There is racism in the US, but it’s not as widespread or as deliberate as you make it seem.
I hope NAAJA’s petition to UNITY is approved.
Can you define racism for me?
Katz_killer “Ok Ray, I believe you. Arabs suffer from more bigotry than blacks and Latinos which is why they statistically graduate from college in higher percentages and and earn more money per household than even whites do!”
But that’s true of Jews too, according to the FBI website Jews have a higher percentage of hate crimes, yet they have high graduation colege rates, they are disproportionately high representation in government, media and many other fields.
It could be that Jews have a higher rate of reporting hate crimes and does not represent the percentages that actually occur.
Who is the one to decide when a hate crime occcurs? Bias may result in inaccurate statistics.
RandallJones “It could be that Jews have a higher rate of reporting hate crimes and does not represent the percentages that actually occur.”
Right, many Latinos may not report hate crimes which would include housing and job discrimination because they may not be fluent in English and they don’t know how or where to go to report a hate crime. The same is true with Blacks/African Americans.
Hi, Jina,
I’m trying to distinguish between discrimination that results from racism — belief in the inherent superiority of a particular race — and the exact same discriminatory action taken from a different and legitimate motive.
For example, say I’m a white atheist landlord with an apartment to rent and two black applicants show up, one Christian and one Muslim. If I’m racist I won’t rent to either of them, I’ll wait for a white guy to come along. If I’m not racist then I don’t care that they’re black, but do I care that one of them is Muslim? The odds that either of them is dangerous are very, very low, but the Christian is statistically safer, so I rent to him.
From the Black Muslim’s point of view the result (discrimination) is the same, but in one case the motive is racism and in the other it is prudence. That’s what I meant by how the suspicion and distrust Americans are experiencing for Muslims and Middle Easterners isn’t always racist, but does result in discrimination. Of course, under US law I get sued either way
Racism is relative … you can hate one person of one race today and be a racist and then hate someone else tomorrow …
The fact is the US government discriminates against Arabs and Muslims and 1) don;’t include us in the census so we don’t even know how many of us there really are 2) don’t consider acts of hatred against Arabs and Muslims real hate crimes, otherwiose they would be prosecuting more cases and they don’t and 3) there is no system to process anti-Arab and anti-Muslim hate crimes int he US … try filing a hate crime charge as an Arab or a Muslim in America. Good luck. They get thrown out by the judicial system often — the system doesbn’t keep statistics based on the race or religion of cases tossed so you can’t identify it factually, only anecdotally. And, the system has so few Arabs and Muslims in it, which is on its face evidence of discrimination …
Ray Hanania
Grumpy, now can you point to me what statistic that shows Arab as danger to America, which makes people take these prudent measures.
Jina,
I don’t see anyone else with statistics, only anecdotes, so here’s an anecdote:
Once upon a time there was a place called the World Trade Center…
Come on, Jina: what is the biggest threat to America today, aside from our own politicians?
Speaking of the FBI website, are you aware the FBI web page for Usama Ben Laden does not list the 9/11 attack as one of his crimes? See http://www.fbi.gov/wanted/terrorists/terbinladen.htm
Why wouldn’t an attack that resulted in the death of 3,000 Americans be specified on Ben Laden list of crimes?
Ed Haas investigated this
See complete article at http://www.teamliberty.net/id267.html
Are you aware that there are many non-Muslims around the world that question the official 9/11 government explanation? Here is just one of many websites that does this http://www.911truth.org/
Your foreign policies.
Hey Grumpy And RJ
Once upon a time, there was a place called “Iraq.” A dictator there, financed by Donald Rumsfeld and past US Administrations, was killing his citizens and no one cared. But then one day Saddam decided to invade Kuwait, believing he got the green light from a US Diplomat from a White House friendly to him, and then the Bush administration (which is tied to the hip of the Saudi Royal Family) decided to fight a war to punish Iraq. And millions of Iraqis were killed.
Of course, there are no statistics to cite regarding the number of innocent Iraqis killed by US Actions in “Operation Dessert Storm” nor are there any statistics to prove the number of Iraqi civilians murdered by rampaging war criminal members of the U.S. Marines now “serving” in the Illegal war in Iraq today. (And I’m a US Military veteran).
So I guess the fact that we have murdered thousands of Arabs doesn’t count for anything because statistics don’t exist to prove the Bush administration war crimes?
And who is living with their head in the sand?
Jina, sometimes we can’t argue with someone who is not interested in learning, but only interested in building Walls and pretending they are fences.
Ray Hanania
http://www.hanania.com
“There are several Arab American journalism organizations. Why are we not surprised none of them will work together?”
Ray I can answer your question. Becuase no one in the Arab American community respects you. On this site you side with Arabs and on Israeli sites you side with Jews. On top of that you send out emails asking for $30 to make some kind of ID for your so called journalists association. What a sorry attempt of profiting from Arab American students. I always heard you were a real shady character and you proved all your critics right. And by the way all the organizations do work together they just don’t want to work with you.
Ray,
WTC came up in response to a question about why average American citizens feel threatened by Arabs and/or Muslims. If you want to change the subject to America’s offenses then that’s fine: it is your thread. Just don’t pretend that you addressed the issue that was being discussed.
Grumpy,
If the maisntream media would provide the information I have provided as well as the history of U.S. relationships with Muslim extremists and agent provocateurs, the average American citizen would not feel threatened by Arabs and/or Muslims.
Actually there is a growing grass roots movement (many non-Muslims) questioning the official 9/11 story.
Ramzi wrote, “And by the way all the organizations do work together they just don’t want to work with you.”
Really? Do they have a website that provides news not found in the mainstream media?
Arabs and Muslims have a long way to go to do the type of journalism that can counter the constant negative and/or wrong information provided by the mainstream media.
There also needs to be a Muslim version of the Israeli organization MEMRI TV. Why hasn’t this happened?
What is your opinion, Randall? Are you saying that 9/11 was NOT the work of Muslims?
Grumpy,
I don’t know who did it. THere are a lot of unanswered questions. More money and time was spent investigating President Clinton’s sexual escapades than was spent on investigating 9/11.
Then what the HELL is your point?
You must be really slow.
Grumpy.
Visit http://www.911truth.org/to learn more about why I doubt the official mainstream media’s explanation of what happened.
Randall, you’ve said three times that 9/11 conspiracy theories exist (no kidding!). You have yet to say how it relates to the topic at hand.
Jina, if you’re so much faster than I then perhaps you could tell me what Randall’s point is? His implication is obvious, but he hasn’t had the stones to step up and just say it. Do you?
That insult was pretty lame, btw: were you pressed for time?
Grumpy,
You are the one who wrote, “That being said, you’re correct (IMO) that suspicion and distrust (even fear) of Muslims of any race and Arabs of any religion has been rising in America for some tme: does that surprise anyone?”
You are the one who bought up the WTC, so I was pointing out the there was a problem with the official investigation of 9/11.
The U.S. has waged a “war on terror” without fully investigating 9/11. Many Ameircan soldiers beleived we invaded Iraq because of 9/11. More terrorist attacks have occured since the “war on terror” began
THere needs to be a greater effort by Arab and non-Arab journalists to investigate what the governmets claims about the “war ion terror.”