5 homosexual men sentenced to 3 years of prison in Egypt

by

An Egyptian court convicted five men Wednesday on charges of homosexual behavior and sentenced them to three years in prison, officials said.

Ramadan, a lawyer with the Egyptian Initiative for Personal Rights, said the five men were abused and tortured over the past several months to “extract confessions” from them.

- The AP

It still escapes me why homosexuality is considered a crime in many countries across the Arab and Muslim world, despite Islam not permitting it. A sin, yes. I can understand that. But a strict and punishable crime? One that can get you imprisoned, or hanged?

Though homosexuality isn’t technically illegal in Egypt, police have been cracking down, some say, to appease religious leaders.

- Queerty

We have debated many times here on whether or not homosexuality should be tolerated and whether or not their human rights should be fought for.

But, I ask you this question upon reading this horrible news today, should homosexuality be considered a crime? Should people be imprisoned and tortured merely for their sexual orientation?

Here, I am not talking about human rights in the sense that homosexuals are accepted entirely in society (even though I fully agree with this,) because we have already discussed that here. I am talking about your opinions on the strict forms of punishment; imprisoning or hanging gay people. This is a question towards people who do not tolerate gays, but haven’t really expressed how society or the government should react.

I still have hope for those who do not tolerate gay people and justify societal abuse against them. I’m wondering whether such people can support their oppression via censorship and societal unacceptance, and yet still disagree with these unjust sentences.

Or if you have no tolerance whatsoever, I guess you support both. Do you really think homosexuality is linked to “moral corruption”? If so, why and how? A lot of people answer this question by talking about gay bars, gay parties, distancing youth from religion, et al. But I wonder, don’t all of these “immoral” things exist within heterosexuality too? Strip clubs, alcohol-ridden casinos, sex trade, premarital sex? So really gay people are not contributing to that just for being gay. There are many gay people who were driven to suicide because they simply can’t change who they are or their sexual orientation. Lovers have died for each other. It’s more serious than what many people here seem to think.

What’s your view? Is sentencing gay people to death or imprisonment really the actions of a just society? If you have no tolerance for gays and think they have no place in our countries then what do you suggest? Kill them?

PS – Many Lebanese homosexuals have come out of the closet. I wonder when we can say the same for other Arab countries.

[youtube]http://youtube.com/watch?v=hV2VzyjQcK0[/youtube]