Stereotyping Islam..

by Lou (Saudi Arabia)

June 27th, 2008
7 Comments

(This topic is a message to any non-Arab muslim or non-muslim in specific, and to all in general)

When your around for Modern muslim images, You’d expect a picture of some angry mob burning down a chinese made American flag, or a turban wearing bearded fellow who’s yelling the name of Allah while waving around a sword, which are indeed some of the many images Islam is being portrayed in these days.. But Am not talking about that kind of Stereotyping, people already talked about it enough..

What am talking about is the Stereotyping of Islam that our society, Saudi Arabia, and the muslim and non muslim societies in general have of any religious figure..

(google a picture of the Religious Authority in Saudi)

When did islam turn into a dress-coded religion? Have we adopted the fact that when someone turns religious, there’s a certain uniform he has to wear?

The thobe, The Ega’al-less Shumakh, the White Ghutra, The Robe (Bisht).. All of the above, if you’re that much religious..

Mind you the inconvenience it may cause to new muslims in non-arab countries, Islam is a flexible religion that is no need of a dress code, our muslim actions and behavior speak loud enough of who we are and what we do.. Restricting our thoughts and imagination to the idea that you have to be a Thobe-Wearing muslim to be a Complete muslim is silly, to even wear that to enter Heaven is stupid.. I came across many Muslims and Muslim reverts who all agree on the fact that the Thobe is the official muslim uniform.. It’s NOT.. Simple, see?

Ok, maybe other heavenly religions already adopted certain uniforms that categorizes it’s participants.. You have the White Collared priests, the Black Hatted Jews, and the Orange-like monks of Tibet and so on.. Islam, however, never specified a certain type of clothing more than rules on what you should wear and how you should wear it, unless you’re off to Hajj or Umra.. For example, preaching of islam’s dress codes that preach modesty, as a muslim i shouldn’t let any piece of clothing i wear (if it happens to cover my legs) to exceed my ankles..This is to Avoid the image that abundance in length is a sign of luxury, in opposition of the poverty image of small shredded clothes.. I should stay away from certain fabrics that gloat of my social status and stick to practical ones that help me do my daily tasks.. i can be stylish, but fabrics like Silk for instance, shouldn’t be used by a man.. I should also refrain from clothing that doesn’t belong to my gender in the common understanding of clothing.. Yes, travesties can’t be muslims..

However, it is not mentioned in Islam nor in different sayings of the prophet PBUH that you should wear a thobe and/or a ghutra.. You can shop from Giordano, buy some Sketchers, wear a Puma and still be a muslim.. a Devoted muslim too.. See, in Islam, we don’t need clothes to speak of who we are, like i mentioned before, it’s our actions.. Like for example, the shaved Mustache and the beard (that should be as long as a closed fist placed under one’s chin) are a sign of someone who’s deeply knowledgeable in Islam and highly devoted; it’s not the Thobe..

My message now goes straight to the new muslim reverts, The thobe is not the Muslim wear, so don’t throw away your clothes just yet.. I met several new muslim reverts who told me that they actually stopped buying pants and shirts ever since they became muslim.. Some of them actually suffered going through the process of tailoring one.. Now, all this fashion journey to nowhere leads to no where.. Islam is not that hard, nor it requires all this mumbo jumbo arabian image to fully be a Muslim..

Another part of this problem lies In Saudi Arabia, Where many still believe that the Thobe and Ghutra are a sign or religiousness, while casual t-shirts and Jeans are just silly arabs trying to act American.. Not western, specifically american.. And that is both wrong and stupid.. Last time i checked, when i wore a thobe in my Engagement, it serves the point of showing that am Celebrating, since i had those textures tailored on it as ornaments, and it gives out that am a Saudi on a special occasion.. Doesn’t mean that am more muslim than anyone else.. Plus, in despite of the pros, the cons are that the thobe is very restricting in movement, not that practical and it’s highly flammable.. So, even if islam wanted a uniform, that would be my last choice.. It’s ok as a cultural trademark, The greek culture has their own set of flammable threads too, it’s just clothes.. The only clothing in Islam that has been specified in the Quran and Sunna is the Ehram.. Other than that, go wild, within the limits of course, which is another topic..

Sticking to the topic in hand..

a Fat bearded muslim, wearing the whole gear, thobe and a Ega’al-less shumakh, walking around dragging his wife behind him and beating his kids, while still having time to pray to Allah, ironically, is in no way similar to another Muslim, wearing the whole gear, and good to his wife and son..

When we actually start believing that a certain dress code is a true representation of a school of thought or a spiritual religion, subconsciously and consciously we’d start to believe that the actions of those who wear it are true representations of it.. Which is wrong..

Anyone knows if there’s a Banana Republic opening in Jeddah soon? :D
.
.
.
Yours,

Lou..

p.s. i miss you guys :)

BOOKMARK THIS ARTICLE

related posts

Esra'a (Bahrain)

June 27, 2008

Good post Lou, and we missed you too! I am always shocked when I see foreign converts to Islam convert their lifestyles too and not just their core beliefs.

You don’t have to change your name to “Abdul Rahman” to be a Muslim. Any John Smith can be a Muslim. No beard or thobe required. Just be yourself, it’s what inside your mind and faith that counts, not your attire!

I hope the right people read your post.

Sayeed

June 27, 2008

Esra’a & Lou thanks to both of you for your post, beard is not a sign of good muslim, being a big fan of Elvis if I would have kept thick sideburns that does not mean I am not a goodlooking guy or bad singer likewise being a big fan of our beloved prophet (pbuh) if I keep beard does it mean I am a bad Muslim? not necessarily. Being an Arab I have been gifted with the language of Qur’an & Hadith but I am not proud as an Arab but as a Muslim just like my other non-arab Muslim brothers. We should not have doubt on their sincerity brothers. ‘no Arab is better than a non-Arab, no non-Arab is better than an Arab – Prophet (pbuh) at his last sermon’. So brothers let’s wake up now, let’s try to mark who is the real enemy of Islam. If we are not allowed to talk against our King who’s being sold to west at $21b a year, lets not atleast pounce over those simple non-arab Muslim brothers who are striving their life-long to brush up Arabic to understand Qur’an. Togather we are strong, let’s not divide Ummah.

Lou (Saudi Arabia)

June 27, 2008

Esra’a:
I can never thank you enough for your support.. :)

However, i would like to clear out, as long as your foreign name doesn’t harm the sanctity of your islam, nor does it harm Allah or Islam in any way in meaning or concept, then it’s your identity.. Many fellow muslims from pakistan still hold their name dear, and once you know the meaning of their name, you’d know how beautiful it is.. However, The prophet PBUH did mention that most favored names are those that fall under the Mohammed and Abdullah Categories, Like Ahmed, Abdullah, Hamid, Mohammed and so on.. It’s a Sunna, so not following that won’t put you in the sinner scale, but doing it will give you that much more Hasanat.. As long as there is free well in someone’s choice, without the pressure of society or the faulty understanding of islam, then it’s all ok.. Islam is a religion of Ease, not the other way around..

Sayeed:
“Togather we are strong, let’s not divide Ummah.” Thank you for this amazing contribution to the topic.. :) much obliged, brother..

Halalhippie /Denmark

June 27, 2008

Reality check: A Saudi saying Islam is an “inner thing”, not a matter of appearance. Just as I thought Islam had turned into a who’s-the-most-hardliner-contest. Bravo!

What’s the deal with a convert having to adopt an Arabic name ? Suppose my (Scandinavian) name meant “Spear of Thor, the God of Thunder” – as pagan as it gets, would I have to change my name, should I re-vert ?

Esra'a (Bahrain)

June 27, 2008

What’s the deal with a convert having to adopt an Arabic name ? Suppose my (Scandinavian) name meant “Spear of Thor, the God of Thunder” – as pagan as it gets, would I have to change my name, should I re-vert ?

Hi Halal.

Your question has been answered within Lou’s post and also within the comments above, and the answer is no. We as Muslims don’t understand why other Muslim converts feel the need to change their name and appearance, because it does not matter. If your name was Thor the Great, you are not required to change your name, but most do because somehow it makes them feel more in tune with the religion. People change things from “Mary” to “Mariam” and “Elias” to “Isa.” This is a personal decision that is personally justified by the convert, and not by the religion itself.

A lot of converts unfortunately mistake the Arab culture for Islamic culture. There are many things we do as Arabs that we are not required to do as Muslims, but converts adopt those things too, thinking it makes them more Muslim simply because Arab Muslims tend to do it.

This faith, most people don’t understand, is a very spiritual one. What matters in your heart and mind matters much more than what you look like on the outside. If you’re a bad Muslim, or a bad person, a veil and a thobe won’t change that. If you’re a good person and a good Muslim, not having a veil, beard and a thobe won’t change that. Pure Muslim converts understand and apply this concept. But many other converts don’t, and feel the need to dress and act like Arabs (Arabs make up a small population of worldwide Muslims, so doing this doesn’t even make sense.)

Halalhippie /Denmark

June 27, 2008

Thank you Esra’a, for your patient and thorough explanation. It has always puzzled me why some converts try to be more Arab than the royal Saudis.

“A lot of converts unfortunately mistake the Arab culture for Islamic culture” And, may I add, so do a number of Arabs, and a whole lot of Westerners.

ME Faith - Middle East Interfaith Blogger Network » Blog Archive » Stereotyping Islam..

June 27, 2008

[...] Mideast Youth – Thinking AheadArticle: Stereotyping Islam..Originaly Posted On: 2008-06-27 [...]

insert your comment

Connect with Facebook

Feel free to take part in our discussions and debates. Please be respectful and aware that what you say is only your opinion and may not agree with other points of views. Absolutely no hate speech or defamation will be tolerated. Be smart and comment smart. Read our comment policy to find out how not to annoy us.

Try this!