Dear Critics

One of the most recurring questions we receive concerning our diverse projects is the motive behind the launch of such an initiative. References would be made to other cases of human rights abuse, comparisons would be made between the two situations and ultimately the verdict would be that we’re either hypocritical or simply ineffective.

The decision to launch a new project is not made arbitrarily; we monitor the situation closely and take several factors into account, the most important being whether the group/cause we wish to launch a project on behalf of is sufficiently represented. MideastYouth.com strives to provide a platform for groups and causes that are un(der)-represented within our societies, and build bridges where none have existed, making sure to do so in an innovative manner.

It’s extremely patronizing and downright insulting when a project of ours is struck down and made light of by accusations that we’re “not doing enough”. But it’s even more patronizing for victims of abuse and violation when their suffering is deemed less worthy than others’. As observers, it’s easy for us to reach conclusions based on inaccurate parameters, but what right do we have to make such judgements?

One project that has been subjected to such criticism is BahaiRights.org. Looking at it from a purely statistical perspective, the persecution of Baha’is in modern times is unlikely to raise red flags; 200 deaths over 3 decades pales in comparison to other genocides. But it’s precisely because of that we believe the project is crucial. Iran may have abandoned mass executions, but it has only done so to pursue a more silent (and dare I say, effective) form of persecution. One execution is likely to garner more attention that the systematic expulsion of hundreds of Baha’i students from universities.

It’s unrealistic to expect us to personally launch a campaign for every issue the region faces; we still operate with limited financial means and manpower.

But if you feel that there’s a worthy cause that requires active campaigning, then by all means don’t  just sit back and accuse us of “ignoring” it; do something. If you require any form of assistance, contact us and we would gladly assist you in setting up a campaign and forming the right connections, so long as it’s within our means.

It’s also unrealistic and plain ridiculous to charge in here demanding us to apologize for every single crime carried out by an Arab/Muslim/etc.  Personally, I would readily condemn human rights violations and violence, I distance myself from and denounce its perpetrators, but I would never apologize for an act simply because it was carried out allegedly under my name. The way I see it, an apology is an admission of guilt, and a legitimization of the acts.

But if you do insist on demanding an apology, kindly provide us with adequate proof that you have condemned and lobbied against every rights violation perpetrated by members of your ethnicity, religious group or nationality. Then, and only then, can a serious discussion on apologies be undertaken.

We truly value feedback from our community and readers, and constantly adjust, adapt and evolve based on the commentary we receive. But please – be realistic in your demands of us.

Bookmark this article

•     
•     
•     
•     
•     
•     
•     
•     
•     
•     
•     
•     
•     
•     

E-mail this article to a friend

* Required Field

Your Name: *

Your E-Mail: *

Your Remark:

Friend's Name: *

Separate multiple entries with a comma. Maximum 5 entries.

Friend's E-Mail: *

Separate multiple entries with a comma. Maximum 5 entries.

Image Verification: *

 Loading ...

Close